The Historical Construction of National Consciousness: Selected Writings

Jenő Szűcs

book: The Historical Construction of National Consciousness

Open Access Published by Central European University Press 2022

The Historical Construction of National Consciousness

Selected Writings

Jenő Szűcs
Edited by: Gábor Klaniczay , Balázs Trencsényi and Gábor Gyáni
Funded by: Opening the Future

https://doi.org/10.1515/9789633864753

Overview
Contents

About this book

A long essay entitled Three Historical Regions of Europe, appearing first in a samizdat volume in Budapest in 1980, instantly put its author into the forefront of the transnational debate on Central Europe, alongside such intellectual luminaries as Milan Kundera and Czesław Miłosz. The present volume offers English-language readers a rich selection of the depth and breadth of the legacy of Jenő Szűcs (1928–1988).

The selection documents Szűcs’s seminal contribution to many contemporary debates in historical anthropology, nationalism studies, and conceptual history. It contains his key texts on the history of national consciousness and patterns of collective identity, as well as medieval and early modern political thought. The works published here, most of them previously unavailable in English, provide a sophisticated analysis of a wide range of subjects from the myths of origins of Hungarians before Christianization to the political and religious ideology of the Dózsa peasant uprising in 1514, the medieval roots of civil society, or the revival of ethnic nationalism during the communist era. The volume, with an introduction by the editors locating Szűcs in a transnational context, offers a unique insight into the complex and sensitive debate on national identity in post-1945 East Central Europe.

Author / Editor information

Szűcs Jenő :

Jenő Szűcs (1928-1988) was a Hungarian historian.

Klaniczay Gábor :

Gábor Klaniczay is University Professor of Medieval Studies at the Central European University.

Trencsényi Balázs :

Balázs Trencsényi is a Professor at the History Department of Central European University.

Gyáni Gábor :

Gábor Gyáni is Senior Research Fellow at the Institute of History of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences.

Reviews

Gabriella Erdélyi:
"A consensus prevails that Szűcs was a veritable historian. He was quick to dismiss Marxism and used an empirical, rather than an ideological, historical approach. But in fact, he became famous for what is highly ideological in his work: his analysis of the historical roots of a tripartite Europe as opposed to the dual model of Cold War Europe, which was a hot—partly ideological—topic in the 1980s." https://scholar.google.com/scholar_url?url=https://ojs.elte.hu/hsce/article/download/5415/5298&hl=hu&sa=X&d=5735065785168522251&ei=t1fLZOzQOcizywTom4uICg&scisig=AFWwaeYOPU1tep_yzSJXRUdFSZgO&oi=scholaralrt&html=&pos=3&folt=kw

László Kontler:
"This fine volume makes available seven classic studies with an excellent editorial introduction and further helpful apparatus to contextualize the emblematic Hungarian historian’s oeuvre. Most of the studies address the ‘historical construction of national consciousness’. Besides, the volume also includes a new translation of Szűcs’s seminal contribution to the ‘Central Europe’ debate of the 1980s by way of a grandiose outline of the longue durée development of ‘structures’ in the three historical regions of Europe. The issues these writings address are as ‘hot’ in the Hungary of the 2020s, and perhaps more widely, as they were in the 1960s–1980s." https://scholar.google.com/scholar_url?url=https://ojs.elte.hu/hsce/article/download/5417/5299&hl=hu&sa=X&d=13169601168701465614&ei=t1fLZOzQOcizywTom4uICg&scisig=AFWwaeZ0GUpiqKYd-7TbU4etHeQy&oi=scholaralrt&html=&pos=2&folt=kw

Guido Franzinetti:
"Not only have the three editors assembled a collection of essays previously unavailable as a set but have also produced an accessible and rigorous translation of the texts. Last but not least, they have finally provided (at least for non-Hungarian readers) what was always missing in the excessively cursory discussions of Szűcs’s work: context. This is no minor achievement. Szűcs’s oeuvre deserves a much wider audience and a much wider discussion. It is up to non-Hungarian historians to take up the challenge." https://scholar.google.com/scholar_url?url=https://ojs.elte.hu/hsce/article/download/5433/5300&hl=hu&sa=X&d=9641245107997327584&ei=t1fLZOzQOcizywTom4uICg&scisig=AFWwaebCxyeyKgmWXoli6khHgc0k&oi=scholaralrt&html=&pos=0&folt=kw

Patrick J. Geary:

Jenő Szűcs was a pioneering figure in the constructivist analysis of ethnic and national identities from late Antiquity through the Middle Ages, but also a major critic of the misuses of national past in his native Hungary. The full scope of his extraordinary scholarship has been too long ignored in the English reading world, and this sensitive translation of his most significant publications makes available to a wide public the breadth of his analyses of nation, ethnic consciousness and political ideology when once more these issues are at the forefront of European political debate.

Topics

Frontmatter Publicly Available Download PDF	i
Contents Publicly Available Download PDF	v
Introduction: Reading and Rereading Jenő Szűcs Gábor Gyáni, Gábor Klaniczay and Balázs Trencsényi Open Access Download PDF	1
“Nationality” and “National Consciousness” in the Middle Ages: Towards the Development of a Common Conceptual Language Open Access Download PDF	25
“Gentilism”: The Question of Barbarian Ethnic Consciousness Open Access Download PDF	85
Theoretical Elements in Master Simon of Kéza’s Gesta Hungarorum (1282–1285) Open Access Download PDF	109
Nation and People in the Late Middle Ages Open Access Download PDF	153
The Ideology of György Dózsa’s Peasant War Open Access Download PDF	177
The Three Historical Regions of Europe Open Access Download PDF	231
Questions of “Origins” and National Consciousness Open Access Download PDF	299
A Bibliography of Published Works by Jenő Szűcs Open Access Download PDF	337
Index Open Access Download PDF	345

Language: English
Publisher: Central European University Press
Audience: Professional and scholarly;
Pages
- Main content: 360
Keywords: historiography; nationalism; conceptual history; national identity; ethnic identity

eBook

Published: September 20, 2022
ISBN: 9789633864753